The concept of school vouchers, which allows public tax dollars to be used for private schooling or homeschooling, is often touted as a way to increase educational options and improve outcomes. While this might be appealing in theory, over 40 years of research on voucher programs reveals extremely limited evidence that supports their effectiveness. Rather, the majority of studies reveal that vouchers fail to improve academic performance and, in some cases, negatively affect student learning. This lack of consistent positive results raises significant concerns about the viability of vouchers as a strategy for enhancing education.
If you had been following an exercise routine for 40 years and hadn't seen positive results—or worse, your health actually declined—would you continue with that routine? Yet, despite limited, supporting data on the effectiveness of Utah's voucher program after its first year, plans are underway to increase funding for vouchers by 200% in the next legislative session. This decision raises serious concerns about legislators committing substantial taxpayer dollars without solid evidence for improving student outcomes.